Skip to main content

Physics Library

Free Physics Study Material for CSIR NET, IIT JAM, GATE, JEST & TIFR

by Pravegaa Education

Chapter 15 — Scientific Reasoning and Estimation

Concepts, worked examples and 33 CSIR NET-JRF Part A questions (December 2016 – December 2025) with full solutions. Click Show solution under any question.

Concepts

15.1 Reasoning from principles

The questions of this chapter describe an everyday situation (a ball on a slope, a melting ice cube, a leaf under a coloured lamp, a drip feeding a patient) and ask what must happen. They do not require specialist knowledge. They require us to identify the one principle that governs the situation, to apply it without being distracted by irrelevant detail, and to check the conclusion against a limiting case. A question that seems to need a long calculation usually yields to a conservation law, a proportionality or a symmetry; a question that seems to need none often hides a quantitative trap, such as an average taken over the wrong variable.

Two habits are worth forming. The first is to ask what is conserved or common to the situations being compared: the mass of melting ice, the length of track a wheel rolls over, the angular speed of a rigid cart. The second is to test an option by pushing the situation to an extreme. If a statement claims that a quantity “moves downward all the way”, consider what happens when the container is nearly empty; if a statement claims that a result depends on distance, consider a mirror placed very close and very far.

15.2 Mechanics and fluids

A body moving through a medium experiences a retarding force that grows with its speed. For a force proportional to the speed, \(f = kV\), a body of mass \(m\) moving down a slope of inclination \(\theta\) obeys

\[m\frac{dV}{dt} = mg\sin\theta - kV,\qquad V(t) = \frac{mg\sin\theta}{k}\left(1 - e^{-kt/m}\right).\]

The speed rises monotonically towards the terminal value \(V_T = mg\sin\theta/k\), at which the driving force and the drag balance. Hence a body that has travelled further down the same slope is moving faster, and experiences a larger drag.

A rigid body rotating about an axis has a single angular speed \(\omega\), and a point at distance \(r\) from the axis moves with speed \(v = \omega r\). A cart turning on a circular track is such a body: its outer wheels travel a larger circle in the same time and must therefore turn faster than the inner ones. A wheel rolling without slipping covers a distance equal to the arc of its rim that touches the ground; one revolution of a wheel of diameter \(d\) moves it forward by \(\pi d\). Gears in mesh pass equal numbers of teeth across the point of contact, so two meshing wheels with \(n_1\) and \(n_2\) teeth return to their initial relative position after \(\operatorname{lcm}(n_1,n_2)\) teeth have passed.

The centre of mass of a system of parts is the mass-weighted mean of their positions. When the composition of a system changes, as when water drains from a bucket, the centre of mass need not move monotonically: it follows whichever part dominates the mass at each stage.

A floating body displaces its own weight of liquid (Archimedes’ principle). If ice of density \(\rho_i\) and volume \(V\) floats in water of density \(\rho_w\), the submerged volume is \(V_{\text{sub}} = \rho_i V/\rho_w\). When the ice melts, its mass \(\rho_i V\) becomes water of volume \(\rho_i V/\rho_w\), which is exactly \(V_{\text{sub}}\):

\[\boxed{\text{floating ice melts without changing the water level.}}\]

The lift on an aircraft wing is the upward aerodynamic force that supports its weight. It is upward throughout flight; what changes in climbing or descending is only its magnitude relative to the weight.

For a body executing simple harmonic motion \(\theta = \theta_0\sin\omega t\), the time spent in an interval \(d\theta\) is \(d\theta/\lvert\dot\theta\rvert\), and \(\lvert\dot\theta\rvert = \omega\sqrt{\theta_0^2 - \theta^2}\). The probability of finding the body in \(d\theta\) is therefore proportional to \(1/\sqrt{\theta_0^2 - \theta^2}\), which is least at the centre, where the body moves fastest, and greatest near the turning points, where it momentarily comes to rest.

15.3 Light and vision

An object has no colour of its own: it appears in the colour of the light it reflects. A leaf looks green because it reflects green light and absorbs the rest; illuminated by light containing no green, it reflects little and appears dark. The blue of the daytime sky arises from Rayleigh scattering by air molecules, whose strength varies as \(\lambda^{-4}\) and so favours short wavelengths. Where there is no atmosphere, as on the Moon, nothing scatters sunlight towards the observer and the sky is black even in daytime.

In a plane mirror the angle of reflection equals the angle of incidence, and the image is as far behind the mirror as the object is in front. Light from a person’s feet reaches the eye after reflection at a point of the mirror midway in height between the eye and the feet; light from the top of the head is reflected midway between the eye and the top of the head. The mirror needs to span only these two points, so the

\[\boxed{\text{minimum mirror height} = \tfrac12\times\text{height of the person}},\]

independent of the distance from the mirror. A ray reflected back and forth between two parallel mirrors a distance \(h\) apart, at an angle \(\phi\) to the normal, advances \(h\tan\phi\) along the mirrors on each passage of length \(h/\cos\phi\); the total path is the horizontal distance covered divided by \(\sin\phi\).

A pinhole camera forms an image because each point of the object illuminates a small patch of the screen, roughly the size of the hole. A larger hole admits more light, in proportion to its area, but enlarges each patch: the image becomes brighter and less sharp. (Very small holes blur the image by diffraction instead, but this matters only for holes much smaller than a millimetre at short distances.)

The apparent size of an object is proportional to its size divided by its distance from the eye. Parts of a structure further from the observer therefore look smaller, and parallel lines receding from the eye appear to converge. A designer who wishes a feature to appear uniform must make its distant parts correspondingly larger.

15.4 Scale, diffusion and collisions

When a body is enlarged by a factor \(L\) in every direction, its surface area grows as \(L^2\) and its volume as \(L^3\), so the surface-to-volume ratio falls as \(1/L\). Processes that supply the interior through the surface, such as the uptake of oxygen or the loss of heat, become relatively less effective as a body grows. Diffusion over a distance \(x\) takes a time of order

\[\boxed{t \sim \frac{x^2}{D}},\]

where \(D\) is the diffusion coefficient, so doubling the distance to be covered quadruples the time. Small organisms without circulatory pumps, such as insects, rely on diffusion and are limited by the shortest dimension of their bodies. Inside a cell, molecules with no transport mechanism reach their destinations by the same random thermal motion.

Continue reading — it's free

Register with your mobile number to unlock the full chapter and all 100+ chapters of the Physics Library.

Register / Login with OTP

Already registered? Use the same button — just verify your number.